Why Mechanic Shops don’t give auto repair quotes over the phone

November 10, 2020

Proud Mommy

Most reputable auto repair shops are put in a bind when asked to give a quote over the phone. Many customers tend to be afraid to come into a shop without having an idea of what a repair will cost. On the other hand once a shop estimates the price for a repair the shop is sort of locked into the price. We recently had a great reminder of why we always ask new customers to please bring their car in for us to give an accurate estimate.

How much does this auto repair cost?

We had a new customer call asking for en estimate on replacing the front air shocks on his W211 Mercedes Benz E500. We asked the customer to bring it in so we could confirm that the air shocks were indeed leaking and there wasn’t anything else that needed replacement in the system. He was insistent on getting a price estimate over the phone. We offered an estimate but explained that there could be other components that might need service or replacement and we would need to diagnose the car to give an accurate quote. Finally when the customer brought the car in we were able to conduct our diagnosis.

Tolima's Auto E500 Air Shock
E500 4Matic Air Shock

What we found during our auto diagnosis

A car with a torn sway bar end link bushing

Once we got the car on our lift we were able to confirm that indeed both air shocks on the W211 Mercedes Benz E500 4Matic were leaking as the customer had stated. But we also found two other front end parts that were needing replacement. The sway bar end links had torn bushings on both sides and the cv axels had one half stuck in the steering knuckle and had split requiring new cv axels. These added parts increased the quote to repair the E500 4Matic properly. Worn sway bar end links cause a thud when going over bumps or braking hard. Worn CV Axels cause noticeable vibrations when accelerating at highway speeds. We had to explain all this to the customer, because if we had gone in and only changed the air shocks the customer would later have experienced thuds and vibrations and he would have think, “That Auto Repair Shop, must have left something loose or damage something else while they were trying to change my air shocks!”. Then our reputation would take a hit with a bad review and phone calls telling to fix what we broke.

In order to avoid these types of situations we at Tolima’s Auto Center always will ask new customers to bring their car for diagnosis and an accurate quote. In this business it is really important to earn trust from new customers. The quickest way to lose that trust is to give one agreeable quote over the phone and then once the car is in our shop to have to call the customer and give them a higher priced quote once we are able to see there are more parts that need replacement. This is generally why most reputable shops rarely give auto repair quotes over the phone.

By Proud Mommy February 20, 2025
The 4th-generation Honda CR-V, was produced from 2012 to 2016, and is a reliable compact SUV popular with many of our customers. It is powered by a 2.4-liter engine and equipped with either a 5-speed automatic (2012–2014) or a CVT (2015–2016), it’s a common sight at our auto repair shop. However, even this popular model […]
By Proud Mommy February 5, 2025
The F15 BMW X5, was produced from 2013 to 2018, and is the third generation of BMW’s flagship luxury SUV. These are pretty popular cars among our customer base. However, like any vehicle, it has its share of common problems that owners and prospective buyers should be aware of. In this blog post, we’ll explore […]
By Proud Mommy December 18, 2024
At Tolima’s Auto Center, a common question we receive is whether we recommend dash cams and if we install them. The answer is a resounding yes, and here’s why you should consider one, particularly in light of recent insurance fraud schemes in New York City. Why Install a Dash Cam? How Dash Cams Work in […]
A person is fixing a brake caliper on a truck.
By Proud Mommy November 14, 2024
Today, we will be answering the most common questions we get about the yearly NY State Inspection. Every year, New Yorkers have to get their vehicles ready for their New York State inspection. The cost of the yearly inspection at the time of this blog post, is $37 to pass or fail. If you fail […]
A volkswagen tiguan is parked on the side of the road
By Proud Mommy September 17, 2024
Many customers contact us for auto body and collision work estimates for their cars, and we always emphasize the auto body and collision estimates based on pictures are rough estimates because we can’t properly estimate the amount of labor and parts for the car to be 100% repaired. We recently had a perfect example of […]
A tool box with a bunch of tools in it
By Proud Mommy August 20, 2024
We had a 2017 BMW 330i customer come in with a coolant leak. The car was regularly losing coolant so it was brought to our shop for diagnosis. We had to figure out why it was consistently losing coolant. For this type of diagnostics, we like to use a coolant pressure testing kit. The tool […]
By Proud Mommy June 26, 2024
Many first time customers come to our shop because their cars were diagnosed and repaired at another shop, but the original problem with their vehicle remains! Due to our proximity to Manhattan in Long Island City, we also get a lot of European vehicles which require advanced diagnostic and auto repair. Which means the car […]
By Proud Mommy June 20, 2024
We have noticed that Tesla has become more and more popular brand of vehicles in NYC and have more customers coming in with Tesla Model 3 owners come to our shop for maintenance and repairs. So we have decided to make a list of the most common issues and repairs we have seen in the […]
By Proud Mommy May 22, 2024
We recently had a customer come in with a 2019 Mercedes Benz GLC 300 that was overheating. The customer told us that it was taken to a different shop where they diagnosed the Mercedes Benz GLC and concluded that the cooling fan was faulty. They proceeded to replace it but the car continued to overheat. […]
By Proud Mommy April 15, 2024
Many customers text, call, or ask us in person, “How often should I change my oil?”. Particularly customers with European cars ask us if the 10,000 mile or 12 month oil change is often enough. And the answer is, it depends! There are multiple variables that determine how often you should change your oil. 10,000 […]