Diagnosing an engine that stalls

September 21, 2020

Proud Mommy

A common reason cars are towed into our auto repair shop is to diagnose an engine that stalls. We start diagnosis by scanning the engine computer. In this case the customer’s car was a 2002 X5 3.0i. We didn’t find any fault codes that would lead us to the cause of the engine stalling. Then we started diagnosing the vehicle. Since it was an older BMW with high miles we wanted to make sure the engine was mechanically sound so we started by putting a socket on the crank pulley and turning the engine by hand to make sure it isn’t binding or has some serious mechanical issues. The engine turned fine so far it seems mechanically sound.

What an engine needs to run

An engine needs three things to run. It needs spark, fuel, and air. So one of those systems was causing the engine stalling issue. The first thing we checked was the air filter and air intake system for obstructions or other issues. All the plastic ducting was clear and the engine was getting a proper reading from the air meter when the engine was temporarily run without stalling. Then we used a spark tester to confirm that the coils were firing properly and there weren’t any frayed wires in the harness that powered the ignition coils. The battery was tested as well and was running great. Finally we moved on to test the fuel system. This model BMW thankfully has a fuel pressure testing port on the fuel rail. We hooked it right up and immediately noticed low fuel pressure. For port injections systems we expect to see about 50 to 60 pounds per square inch of fuel pressure. Also when the engine stalled out the fuel pressure dropped to zero. So we knew that we had to find out what was wrong with the fuel pump. Was it a broken wire? Was the fuel pump bad? Was it a severely clogged fuel filter?

A close up of a gas tank with a hose coming out of it.

Accessing a fuel pump

Depending on the manufacturer accessing a fuel pump can be a breeze or it can be labor intensive. Some manufacturers install an easy access panel under the back seats or in the trunk. Other manufacturers require you to lower the exhaust and part of the rear suspension to access the fuel pump by dropping the whole gas tank. This can make the repair quite expensive when you are paying a shop as it is labor intensive. Thankfully this BMW X5 has an access panel under the rear seat. We accessed the fuel pump and tested the wiring to make sure it is receiving the proper voltage and the wiring is in good condition. Once the wiring was confirmed to be good we moved on to test the actual fuel pump. The fuel pump was likely a factory original due to the markings on it. Then we confirmed that the fuel pump was barely running and would suddenly stop when voltage was increased. We the repaired the car by installing a new Original Equipment Manufacturer fuel pump assembly and whenever you change the fuel pump you must also clean out the gas tank of any debris and change out the fuel filter.

A person is holding a fuel pump in front of a car.

This blog post goes over a little bit of the process that is used to properly diagnose a problem and not simply change parts at expense of our customers. This shows a little bit of the process we go through to fix any problem the right way the first time. It shows how we have built up our reputation and why our customers keep coming back to us for their automotive repairs. If you have any questions or would like to set an appointment please feel free to contact us at Tolima’s Auto Center.

By Proud Mommy February 20, 2025
The 4th-generation Honda CR-V, was produced from 2012 to 2016, and is a reliable compact SUV popular with many of our customers. It is powered by a 2.4-liter engine and equipped with either a 5-speed automatic (2012–2014) or a CVT (2015–2016), it’s a common sight at our auto repair shop. However, even this popular model […]
By Proud Mommy February 5, 2025
The F15 BMW X5, was produced from 2013 to 2018, and is the third generation of BMW’s flagship luxury SUV. These are pretty popular cars among our customer base. However, like any vehicle, it has its share of common problems that owners and prospective buyers should be aware of. In this blog post, we’ll explore […]
By Proud Mommy December 18, 2024
At Tolima’s Auto Center, a common question we receive is whether we recommend dash cams and if we install them. The answer is a resounding yes, and here’s why you should consider one, particularly in light of recent insurance fraud schemes in New York City. Why Install a Dash Cam? How Dash Cams Work in […]
A person is fixing a brake caliper on a truck.
By Proud Mommy November 14, 2024
Today, we will be answering the most common questions we get about the yearly NY State Inspection. Every year, New Yorkers have to get their vehicles ready for their New York State inspection. The cost of the yearly inspection at the time of this blog post, is $37 to pass or fail. If you fail […]
A volkswagen tiguan is parked on the side of the road
By Proud Mommy September 17, 2024
Many customers contact us for auto body and collision work estimates for their cars, and we always emphasize the auto body and collision estimates based on pictures are rough estimates because we can’t properly estimate the amount of labor and parts for the car to be 100% repaired. We recently had a perfect example of […]
A tool box with a bunch of tools in it
By Proud Mommy August 20, 2024
We had a 2017 BMW 330i customer come in with a coolant leak. The car was regularly losing coolant so it was brought to our shop for diagnosis. We had to figure out why it was consistently losing coolant. For this type of diagnostics, we like to use a coolant pressure testing kit. The tool […]
By Proud Mommy June 26, 2024
Many first time customers come to our shop because their cars were diagnosed and repaired at another shop, but the original problem with their vehicle remains! Due to our proximity to Manhattan in Long Island City, we also get a lot of European vehicles which require advanced diagnostic and auto repair. Which means the car […]
By Proud Mommy June 20, 2024
We have noticed that Tesla has become more and more popular brand of vehicles in NYC and have more customers coming in with Tesla Model 3 owners come to our shop for maintenance and repairs. So we have decided to make a list of the most common issues and repairs we have seen in the […]
By Proud Mommy May 22, 2024
We recently had a customer come in with a 2019 Mercedes Benz GLC 300 that was overheating. The customer told us that it was taken to a different shop where they diagnosed the Mercedes Benz GLC and concluded that the cooling fan was faulty. They proceeded to replace it but the car continued to overheat. […]
By Proud Mommy April 15, 2024
Many customers text, call, or ask us in person, “How often should I change my oil?”. Particularly customers with European cars ask us if the 10,000 mile or 12 month oil change is often enough. And the answer is, it depends! There are multiple variables that determine how often you should change your oil. 10,000 […]